When meds aren’t the real medicine


He was 23, a college senior, and lit up when he talked about photography, something he loved.

But every time his excitement broke through, he crushed it with the same line:
“I just need to get my shit together and be more like my dad.”

His dad wanted him to push harder, climb faster, succeed bigger.

But my patient wasn’t even sure he even wanted that life.

And me?

I just wrote him another prescription and sent him on his way.

I maxed him out on Strattera, watched him become poorly compliant, and then never saw him again.

That’s on me.

The medication seemed to be working for his symptoms, but was it helping?

Because what he really needed wasn’t another titration schedule.

He needed someone curious enough to ask...

What does it mean to you if your meds work?

And what if they don’t?

Whose voice is in your head when you swallow that pill?

Did growing up with a diagnosis feel helpful or make you the family scapegoat?

What kind of “care” did you really receive from past doctors and caregivers?

But here’s the truth: most prescribers don’t ask those questions.

We’re trained to listen for symptoms, follow the algorithms, and adjust doses.

That’s exactly what I did with him.

And it’s not just me.

For the past few decades, psychiatric training has leaned hard into the “medical model.”

Biology. Neurotransmitters. Receptors.

It was meant to de-stigmatize mental illness and be more “this isn’t your fault, it’s brain chemistry” but it also stripped out the psychology, which might be the most important part!

The results?

  • Less curiosity about a patient’s story
  • Less time spent on meaning, ambivalence, or unconscious dynamics
  • More patients who feel “broken by biology” instead of empowered to work towards wellness

It’s not that the science is wrong. It’s that the story got lost.

And when the story is lost, the alliance suffers.

And when the alliance suffers, outcomes suffer too.

This week's video is about psychodynamic psychotherapy and how it impacts treatment outcomes!

If my patient had had you, a savvy, thoughtful therapist, in the room, you could’ve stepped in!

You could have named the ambivalence, helped him explore why he didn’t really want medications, and guided him toward what might’ve worked instead.

This is the heart of psychodynamic psychopharmacology.

It’s not just about receptors and doses. It’s about the story.

...The narrative your client carries into the room.

...The way unconscious feelings about illness, identity, and authority sneak into treatment.

But if the story doesn’t change, the outcome rarely does.

As a therapist, here's you can help:

  • Ask your clients what story they’re telling themselves about taking meds
  • Listen for fear, relief, failure, or resentment hiding underneath
  • Bring curiosity where my system usually brings scripts

The best medication in the world won’t fix a bad narrative and no algorithm can replace the power of curiosity!

Help me undo some of the damage from the medical model as psychiatry tries to regain some of it's humanity (and let's make it a little more fun too!)

Cheers to healthy brains,

Dr. B
Jessica Beachkofsky, MD MSCP
Your friendly online psychiatrist!

P.S. Here's your video link for psychodynamic psychopharmacology!

P.P.S. And as mentioned in the video, here's the link to Amazon for the book by Dr. David Mintz

Welcome to Brain Bites with Dr. B!

Brain Bites is all about broadening your reach with easy-to-digest psych knowledge! Join me for quick, interesting medication and brain science tidbits! Elevate your therapy practice with insight and data from your friendly online psychiatrist!

Read more from Welcome to Brain Bites with Dr. B!
Dr. Jessica Beachkofsky, psychiatrist, showing off brain gadgets for neurofeedback

"Warmer... warmer.... WARMER!... HOT!!!" I know you remember the hot/cold game, right Reader? Someone hides something, like a water bottle or a precious heirloom tiara, and there's one person looking for it. Everyone else can give guidance based on temperature where HOT means you're right on top of it!!! (If only it was as easy to find my sunglasses when I don't put them back where they "belong". And I look with my eyes OPEN!) It was a fun game when I was 9 and it was fun to play with a...

Dr Jessica Beachkofsky talks about sleep and CBT-i

I’ve been a psychiatrist for a while. It’s not often that I’m “wowed” by some new piece of information on a topic that has been the bread and butter of what I’ve been doing for almost 20yrs. But reading this article about CBT-i had a fascinating sleep pearl that has nothing to do with the main topic which is how to use CBT-i to help get people off their sleep meds. That magical little tidbit? People who get 7hrs of sleep have lower all-cause morbidity and mortality. Not 6hrs Not 8hrs 7hrs....

Dr. Jessica Beachkofsky MD MSCP talks with a sex therapist about menopause and sex

Remember how I said I was on hiatus to study for my menopause exam? Well…it went even longer than planned because I didn’t realize I’d have to wait six weeks after everyone took the test (over a whole month) to get my results. SIX. WEEKS. Ugh. Here’s the evolution of my thoughts as I worked through the questions... Q1: Ok, here we go. Oh nice, only 3 answer choices! Yay! Q6: Huh. I treated this once as an intern…17 years ago. Come on, brain. Q13: Did you even study for this? Q38: I’m going to...